Mailing List SIMS@mail.stalker.com Message #10315
From: Christian F Buser <mac-christian@subdimension.com>
Subject: SMTP authentication
Date: Mon, 25 Feb 2002 18:08:00 +0100
To: <sims@mail.stalker.com>
X-Mailer: QUALCOMM Windows Eudora Version 5.1
Using SIMS 1.8b9d9, I cannot get SMTP auth to work.

In the SIMS SMTP settings I have:
(X) Advertise AUTH Capability
(X) Allow ETRN for clients only
For 45 seconds, authenticated IPs are treated as clients
(X) Relay for clients only
(X) Verify return paths

However, with Eudora 4.3.3 and 5.x (both paid, on MacOS) I cannot make it work. It always tells me "we do not relay".

The relevant settings in Eudora are correct, as far as I can tell:
SMTP server: mail.rumantsch.ch
(X) Allow authotization
Username and password should be okay, since otherwise I could not receive incoming mails.

Of course I could use "POP before SMTP", but I don't like it, it's cumbersome.  What else did I miss?

Here is the relevant part from the  SIMS log, in case it helps:

17:50:09 5 SMTP-040() Stream Created
17:50:09 4 SMTP-040() Got connection from [212.71.103.177:32843]
17:50:09 4 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) Sending 220-Stalker Internet Mail Server V.1.8b9d9 is ready.\r\n220 ESMTP is spoken here. You are welcome\r\n
17:50:09 5 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) OT 97 of 97 bytes sent, Flags=0
17:50:09 5 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) *Status=22
17:50:09 5 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) Received 19 bytes
17:50:09 4 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) Input Line: XXXX [172.16.7.3]\r
17:50:09 4 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) Sending 500 Unknown command\r\n
17:50:09 5 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) OT 21 of 21 bytes sent, Flags=0
17:50:09 5 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) Received 19 bytes
17:50:09 4 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) Input Line: HELO [172.16.7.3]\r
17:50:09 5 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) *Status=21
17:50:09 4 SMTP-040([172.16.7.3]) Looking for [172.16.7.3]
17:50:10 4 SMTP-040([172.16.7.3]) Sending 250 rumantsch.ch your name is not [172.16.7.3]\r\n
17:50:10 5 SMTP-040([172.16.7.3]) OT 48 of 48 bytes sent, Flags=0
17:50:10 5 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) *Status=22
17:50:10 5 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) Received 6 bytes
17:50:10 4 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) Input Line: RSET\r
17:50:10 4 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) Sending 250 SMTP state reset\r\n
17:50:10 5 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) OT 22 of 22 bytes sent, Flags=0
17:50:10 5 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) *Status=22
17:50:10 5 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) Received 36 bytes
17:50:10 4 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) Input Line: MAIL FROM:<christian@rumantsch.ch>\r
17:50:10 5 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) *Status=25
17:50:10 4 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) Sending 250 <christian@rumantsch.ch> sender accepted\r\n
17:50:10 5 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) OT 46 of 46 bytes sent, Flags=0
17:50:10 5 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) *Status=23
17:50:10 5 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) Received 25 bytes
17:50:10 4 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) Input Line: RCPT TO:<cbuser@mus.ch>\r
17:50:10 5 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) Writing 52 byte at 0
17:50:10 5 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) *Status=32
17:50:10 4 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) Looking for mail.mus.ch
17:50:10 1 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) SPAM? Recipient '<cbuser@mus.ch>' rejected: relaying to [62.12.131.180] is not allowed
17:50:10 4 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) Sending 571 <cbuser@mus.ch> we do not relay.\r\n
17:50:10 5 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) OT 38 of 38 bytes sent, Flags=0
17:50:10 5 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) *Status=23
17:50:10 5 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) Received 6 bytes
17:50:10 4 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) Input Line: QUIT\r
17:50:10 5 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) *Status=29
17:50:10 4 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) Sending 221 rumantsch.ch closing connection\r\n
17:50:10 5 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) OT 37 of 37 bytes sent, Flags=0
17:50:10 5 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) *Status=1
17:50:10 4 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) Closing
17:50:11 5 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) Disconnect Received
17:50:11 5 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) Disconnect Confirmed
17:50:11 4 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) Input Stream ended
17:50:11 5 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) *Status=2
17:50:11 5 SMTP-040([212.71.103.177]) Stream Disposed

Subscribe (FEED) Subscribe (DIGEST) Subscribe (INDEX) Unsubscribe Mail to Listmaster