Mailing List SIMS@mail.stalker.com Message #11392
From: Alan Summerfield <Alan.Summerfield@mail.nbio.uni-heidelberg.de>
Subject: "Mirror to List", 2 whitelisted users, blacklisted domain
Date: Fri, 02 Aug 2002 11:21:42 +0200
To: (SIMS Discussions) <SIMS@mail.stalker.com>
Hello,

I have a router table problem which I hope/I'm sure you guys can solve:


I have a router table entry whereby messages to and from gmx.de are blocked:

gmx.de = error

However, two of our people have such an account and I've therefore included
at the top of the table for each of them:

<xxxx@gmx.de>=xxxx@gmx.de.smtp

and when I send the same message to both recipients they both receive it,
for example:

10:40:54 5 ROUTER Input: Alan(uni-hd.de)
10:40:54 5 ROUTER Parser: Alan@uni-hd.de -> Alan(uni-hd.de)
10:40:54 5 ROUTER Input: xxxx(gmx.de)
10:40:54 5 ROUTER Parser: xxxx@gmx.de -> xxxx(gmx.de)
10:40:54 4 ROUTER mapped to email(xxxx @gmx.de.smtp) (safe)
10:40:54 5 ROUTER Input: xxxx@gmx.de.smtp()
10:40:54 5 ROUTER Parser: xxxx@gmx.de.smtp -> xxxx(gmx.de.smtp)
10:40:54 2 SMTP-146([129.206.50.204]) {S.0000798934} received, 896 bytes
10:40:55 5 ROUTER Input: xxxx(gmx.de)
10:40:55 5 ROUTER Parser: xxxx@gmx.de -> xxxx(gmx.de)
10:40:55 4 ROUTER mapped to email(xxxx @gmx.de.smtp) (safe)
10:40:55 5 ROUTER Input: xxxx@gmx.de.smtp()
10:40:55 5 ROUTER Parser: xxxx@gmx.de.smtp -> xxxx(gmx.de.smtp)
10:40:55 2 SYSTEM [S.0000798934] <B9701236.5024D%Alan@uni-hd.de> 1+0
From:Alan@uni-hd.de
10:40:55 3 SMTP-146([129.206.50.204]) Abort Received, reason=54
10:40:55 3 SMTP-146([129.206.50.204]) Reading Failed. Error Code=-3155.
Read:
10:40:56 2 SMTP-147(relay.uni-heidelberg.de) [S.0000798934] sent, 800 bytes
10:40:56 2 SYSTEM(SMTP) [S.0000798934] sent to (gmx.de)xxxx
10:40:56 2 SYSTEM [S.0000798934] deleted

However, they are included on a mailing list that I've set up using the
"Mirror to List" function, and messages to these recipients fail:

10:09:51 5 ROUTER Input: xxxx(gmx.de)
10:09:51 5 ROUTER Parser: xxxx @gmx.de -> xxxx(gmx.de)
10:09:51 4 ROUTER mapped to email(xxxx @gmx.de.smtp) (safe)
10:09:51 5 ROUTER Input: xxxx@gmx.de.smtp()
10:09:51 5 ROUTER Parser: xxxx@gmx.de.smtp -> xxxx(gmx.de.smtp)
10:09:51 4 ROUTER redirected to email(error) (safe)
10:09:51 5 ROUTER Input: xxxx(error)
10:09:51 5 ROUTER Parser: xxxx@error -> xxxx(error)
10:09:51 5 ROUTER Input: ERROR()
10:09:51 5 ROUTER Parser: ERROR -> ERROR()

The same failure happens with 2 yahoo.com users. Single aol.com and
hotmail.com users, set up in the same way (domain blocked but user
whitelisted at the top of Router table), receive their messages via "Mirror
to List".

So why does a "Mirror to List" message with 2 whitelisted users at a
blacklisted domain cause a problem?


Alan Summerfield

--
Photographer, Network Manager
Neurobiologie der Uni. Heidelberg
Im Neuenheimer Feld 364          69120 Heidelberg          Germany

fon: +49 (6221) 54-5471          fax: +49 (6221) 54-4496
http://neurobiology.uni-hd.de


Subscribe (FEED) Subscribe (DIGEST) Subscribe (INDEX) Unsubscribe Mail to Listmaster